While saints in the United States and Canada currently enjoy great freedom to gather for worship, pressure to bend beliefs and curb convictions exists. Some reading this may very well have already experienced that strain. Where do believers typically feel this tension? A common setting is the workplace. Here, fellow employees may belittle a believer’s faithful walk or employers may threaten loss of employment or promotions when an employee requests accommodations to practice their religious beliefs.
As we move through this new millennium, it often seems that lawmakers are making it increasingly difficult for religious expression and action to take place in the public square. However, in a recent United States Supreme Court case, Groff v. United States Postal Service, 143 S. Ct. 2279, 2023, the Court affirmed (for the present) that in the United States, employers must make religious accommodations for their workers, unless the accommodation has a substantial negative affect on their business.
The facts
In 2019, Gerald Groff tendered his resignation to his employer, the United States Postal Service (USPS), after experiencing seven years of pressure to work on the Sabbath. As the workload increased for his particular postal office, Groff faced increasing pressure and even discipline for not falling in line with his employer’s request to work on Sundays. Groff, an evangelical Christian, held devout beliefs that the Sabbath was for worship and family.
Groff began his work with the USPS in 2012. As Amazon’s collaboration with USPS increased, so, too, did the pressure for Groff to work on Sundays. Anticipating that the tension would not lessen, he changed locations to a much smaller rural postal district, a proactive move he hoped would avoid future issues. However, this same Sunday strain soon found him in his new rural route, and over the course of the next three years, pressure again mounted for Gerald Groff to work Sundays. He requested accommodation for his sincerely held religious beliefs. His employer expressed that the effect of accommodating Groff’s belief (to honor the Sabbath day) caused more than a “de minimis negative impact on the work environment and co-workers” and thus they were not obligated to grant him a Sabbath rest.
The filing
In 2019, Gerald Groff resigned. Shortly thereafter, he filed suit in the local District Court, claiming that under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the USPS could have accommodated his sincerely held religious beliefs “without undue hardship on the conduct of the Postal Service business.” But business, the Postal Service argued, was placed under an undue hardship, as this request for accommodation required Groff’s fellow employees and management to work Sundays to keep up with the flow of parcels and goods.
The case never went to trial at the local level. The District Court (lowest court) granted summary judgment to the USPS (if facts are not in dispute in a case, but rather how the facts are to be interpreted pursuant to the law, the court can rule early in a case). At odds? How to interpret what was the level of “undue hardship.”
Groff appealed the decision. Upon appeal, the Third Circuit affirmed the District Court’s decision, which held that requiring an employer to bear more than a de minimis cost to provide a religious accommodation to an employee was an undue hardship on the employer, and therefore not required. The Third Circuit found that exempting Groff from Sunday work had “imposed on his co-workers, disrupted the workplace and workflow, and diminished employee moral” (Groff. 14).
The final step
Groff filed a request in August 2022 for the Supreme Court to hear his case. In the months following, voluminous religious groups filed Amicus Curiae (friends of the court) briefs to the Court, urging it to take the case. And they did, in January 2023.
Backdrop: Title VII & Interpretive Case History
At the heart of the case was the Supreme Court’s first opportunity in nearly forty years to interpret a small— but vital—portion of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Congress enacted Title VII, making it unlawful for employers to “fail or refuse to hire or to discharge any individual, or otherwise to discriminate against any individual with respect to his compensation, terms, conditions, or privileges of employment, because of such individual’s…religion” (42 USC 2000e2(a)(1). As initial legislation did not define what was meant by “discrimination because of religion,” subsequent administrative regulations issued by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) further enunciated that this portion of law obligated employers “to make reasonable accommodations to the religious needs of employees whenever doing so would not create undue hardship on the conduct of the employer’s business” (29 CFR 1605.1).
This regulatory interpretation faced great criticism from the Sixth Circuit, who maintained that the above regulatory interpretation was actually leading to the establishment of religion! (in the case Dewey v. Reynolds Metals Co., 429 F2d 329). In response, the 1972 Congress placed into law the EEOC’s “undue hardship principle”—seemingly bringing an end to the matter. But defining “undue hardship” would soon be watered down.
In 1977, the Supreme Court’s majority opinion in Hardison v. Trans World Airlines, Inc. included a seemingly small sentence, which inadvertently (or perhaps intentionally?) created a low standard by which employers could terminate an employee seeking religious accommodations, if the accommodation sought had a slight impact on the employer.
In Hardison, an employee experienced a religious conversion and sought relief from his Sabbath (for him Saturday) hours. This conflicted with fellow laborers with more senior union authority at the airline company, and Hardison was terminated. The case focused on “seniority rights” against a “junior employee’s religious practices.” While the thrust of the case dealt with “seniority systems” a byline in the majority opinion read “to require TWA to bear more than a de minimis cost in order to give Hardison Saturdays off is an undue hardship.”
And thus the “de minimis standard” was born. And for over four decades, Congress sat idly by, failing to redefine or clarify an emerging court doctrine that allowed employers to deny even minor religious accommodations sought by employees.
Into the fray
So Groff and his legal team moved forward. But they were not alone.
It is interesting to note that prior to and even after a case reaches the Supreme Court, procedural rules allow interested third parties to file supporting succinct briefs called Amicus Curiae to advise the Court. Curious as to which organizations may have been particularly interested in Groff’s case? The Sikh Coalition, The Council on American-Islamic Relations, Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations, Seventh Day Adventist Church of Canada, Christian Legal Society, Church of Latter Day Saints, American Hindu Coalition, Baptist Groups, Evangelicals and others all submitted Amicus Curiae briefs in support of Groff.
Justice Samuel Alito, who wrote the majority opinion of the Court, noted several of the above Amicus Curiae briefs, writing “a bevy of diverse religious organizations has told this Court that the de minimis test has blessed the denial of even minor accommodations in many cases, making it harder for members of minority faiths to enter the job market” (Groff. 26).
After reviewing the Title VII history outlined above and subsequent misinterpretation from the Harrison case, Justice Alito addressed the interesting fact that by the time the case reached the Court, both the USPS and Groff’s legal team submitted briefs to SCOTUS that took issue with the forty-year-old de minimis test. The USPS (and Amicus Curiae briefs supporting its position) suggested to the Court that it create a standard of “substantial expenditures” or “substantial additional costs.” Groff suggested “significant difficulty or expense” to be the standard.
A new way forward
Justice Alito concluded the following: “We think it is enough to say that an employer must show that the burden of granting an accommodation would result in substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of its particular business” (Groff. 28). That is, “undue hardship” for an employer. “What matters,” Justice Alito continued, “is that courts must apply the test in a manner that takes into account all relevant factors in the case at hand, including the particular accommodations at issue and their practical impact in light of the nature, size, and operating cost of an employer.”
The test was further clarified with two points by Justice Alito. First, the test requires an assessment of possible accommodation’s effects on the “conduct of the employer’s business” (Groff. 29). Meaning, fellow employees’ (or employers’) dislike or negative reaction to a closely held religious belief is not an undue hardship. Nor, the Justice continued, can the action of accommodation of a religious practice or expression be considered “undue” (Groff. 29).
Second, the test means that an employer must reasonably accommodate an employee’s practice of religion and not merely assess the reasonableness of a particular possible accommodation. In short, an employer must consider a wide swath of options, and in Groff’s case Justice Alito concluded, “it would not be enough for an employer to conclude that forcing other employees to work overtime would constitute an undue hardship. Consideration of other options, such as voluntary shift swapping, would also be necessary” (Groff. 29).
The fallout
Public clamor leading up to the written decision’s release on June 29, 2023 feared a decision that would give far too much power to the religious right. When SCOTUS released the decision, as you may have guessed, many religious groups cheered, recognizing that employers now had a much higher burden of proof resting on their shoulders if they wished to avoid religious accommodation for their workers.
But while a new standard had been clarified, what constitutes an actual hardship will need to be sorted out on a case-by-case basis. How far must employers go to accommodate employee religious practices? What degree of costs and disruption will be enough to show undue hardship? These are just a few of the questions that are awaiting answers to be developed.
As a byproduct of the increased standard for employers, a new bulls-eye target is likely to emerge. What constitutes a “sincerely held religious belief?” In the past four decades, courts have not needed to scrutinize an employee’s claim of a religious belief or expression, due to the previous low burden placed on employers. But now? An unintended consequence of this decision may very well be that more heightened scrutiny is directed at employees’ beliefs or practices, questioning whether they are actually “sincerely held” or even “religious beliefs” at all.
The calling to be faithful
While Groff vs. The United States Postal Services is widely heralded (rightly so) as a legal victory for religious employees, the history of four decades of employees’ legal battles who sought employer accommodations in order to continue in their line of work while still remaining faithful to their closely held religious beliefs is a sobering reminder of the world’s efforts to create an environment and perception that faith does not provide the framework for all aspects of our lives.
We should be encouraged by the results of those efforts to preserve our right to worship and give expression of our faith in all aspects of our lives, including vocations and public callings.
Paul, in a letter to his dear friend Titus, understands that we will live our lives in the scrutiny of this world. Unlike a Supreme Court test, still vague and open to interpretation, the instruction to us from Scripture is simple and clear.
“In all things shewing thyself a pattern of good works: in doctrine shewing uncorruptness, gravity, sincerity, sound speech, that cannot be condemned; that he that is of the contrary part may be ashamed, having no evil thing to say of you…. For the grace of God that bringeth salvation, hath appeared to all men, teaching us that, denying ungodliness and worldly lusts, we should live soberly, righteously, and godly, in this present world” (Tit. 2: 7-8, 11-12).