Rev. Joshua Engelsma pastor of the Crete PRC in Crete, Illinois

Previous article in this series: April 2026, p. 250.

 

Article 78: “When an excommunicated person wishes to be reconciled with the congregation by way of repentance, it shall be announced to the congregation before the celebration of the Lord’s Supper or otherwise according to circumstances earlier, to the end that at the next Lord’s Supper (insofar as anyone knows of anything to bring forth to the contrary) he may be reinstated publicly with profession of his conversion, according to the form for this purpose.”1

The cutting off with the ban does not mean to expel the sinner from the congregation forever, but is a last remedy to bring him to repentance. God takes the repentant sinner back in grace; likewise the church. Solomon already taught: “He that covereth his sins shall not prosper: but whoso confesseth and forsaketh them shall have mercy” (Prov. 28:13). Already at the Synod of Dordrecht (1578, Art. 97) the churches also declared that the cutting off should be done for the purpose “that the excommunicated one, stricken by shame, may earnestly consider repentance.”2 Initially, however, there was no fixed provision for the readmission. The consistories and classes established the manner in each case. Yet it soon became apparent that uniformity was necessary. Therefore, the Synod of The Hague (1586) placed in Article 713 the above-printed article concerning readmission into the Church Order, which has remained so until now. The article defines the main principles that will be discussed with readmission.

  1. On what condition it takes place: “When an excommunicated person wishes to be reconciled with the congregation by way of repentance.” Thus on two conditions. The first is that reconciliation with and readmission by the church is desired by the excommunicated one himself. The desire for reconciliation must come from himself. The church also desires and admonishes him to repent, but he must also reveal the desire to be reinstated. The second is that the sincerity of that desire must be evident in his “repentance.” It could be that someone came back with secondary intentions, for instance in order not to miss diaconal care in old age. So the consistory must be convinced that he is motivated by genuine repentance. Not sin itself, but impenitence was the ground for his cutting off. And that “impenitence” can only be removed by “penitence.” If the consistory is not convinced of this, they can set a probationary period to give him the opportunity to show his penitence in word and deed.
  2. That it must be done with the concurrence of the congregation: “it shall be announced to the congregation before the celebration of the Lord’s Supper or otherwise according to circumstances earlier.” The intention is not merely to make a formal statement to the congregation, but to obtain its approbation, that is, its tacit consent, and, “insofar as anyone knows of anything to bring forth to the contrary,” to investigate and remove these objections. This “announcement” or communication to the congregation is included at the beginning of the Form and must therefore be read at least three Sundays in advance.

Which congregation is meant here? The congregation where he was excommunicated, or the congregation where he now lives after a possible relocation? Answer: the congregation where he now lives. He can only become a member of the congregation where he now lives, because each local congregation is an independent church and has its own boundaries, and the consistory there too can only judge his course of life. However, the consistory at this place will correspond with the consistory that excommunicated him, according to the demands of the denominational federation; and in some cases they may require him to reconcile himself with his previous consistory and congregation; but the formal act of readmission must be done by the consistory where he now lives. This [consistory] has to decide. If the previous consistory does not agree, he can appeal to the classis under which the church that wants to receive him falls. Pending the appeal, the readmission must wait.

  1. The manner in which it must be done: “to the end that at the next Lord’s Supper (insofar as anyone knows of anything to bring forth to the contrary) he may be reinstated publicly with profession of his conversion, according to the form for this purpose.” The readmission is here directly associated with the Lord’s Supper. This is in the nature of the matter. In the Lord’s Supper lies the highest expression of ecclesiastical and spiritual communion. The excommunication was an exclusion from the Lord’s Supper in the first place and also from the whole congregation. “Just as it now makes the most impression if one usually imposes the ban at the Lord’s Supper, so it will also be most solemn if the readmittance takes place in the service itself when the Lord’s Supper is being prepared. Immediately after his readmission, the once excommunicated person can then commune with the church” (Dr. A. Kuyper).4 Only when there are urgent reasons, such as when a baptism, a marriage, or a relocation would have to be delayed and it would take too long, can it also take place on an ordinary day of rest.

The readmission itself must be “with profession of his conversion…publicly…following the form for this purpose.” This Form is divided into two parts:

  1. A form of declaration, which must be read to the congregation at least three Sundays in advance and means a. that the sinner is repentant; b. that the consistory asks for the approbation of the congregation; and c. the encouragement to gratitude for the initial conversion.
  2. The actual form, which is broken into two parts:

A doctrinal portion, which a. includes the statement that no legal objections have been filed and the readmission is now taking place; and b. contains the grounds on which the readmittance rests, namely, on the key power (Matt. 18:18).

A liturgical part, in which are set forth a. the confession of guilt of the excommunicated person; b. the act of reinstatement; c. the admonition to the readmitted and to the congregation; and d. the prayer of thanks.


* The following is a translation of Johannes Jansen, Korte Verklaring van de Kerkenordening [A Brief Explanation of the Church Order] (Amsterdam: J. H. Kok, 1923).

1 The article in the church order used by Jansen differs very slightly from the wording of the article in our present church order. The translation of this article comes from Richard De Ridder, ed., The Church Orders of the Sixteenth Century Reformed Churches of the Netherlands Together with Their Social, Political, and Ecclesiastical Context (Grand Rapids: Calvin Theological Seminary, 1987), 360.

2 Quoted in De Ridder, Church Orders, 222.

3 Cf. De Ridder, Church Orders, 360.

4 Jansen does not indicate the source of this quotation from Abraham Kuyper.