Prof. Hanko is professor emeritus of Church History and New Testament in the Protestant Reformed Seminary. (Preceding article in this series: September 1, 2004, p. 469.)
Introduction
John Wesley’s itinerant ministry made a huge impact on ecclesiastical life in the British Isles. While most of his ministry was carried on in England, his influence was felt in Ireland and, to a lesser extent, in Scotland. While the Calvinism of Howell Harris and George Whitefield prevailed in Wales at least for a time, Calvinism deteriorated also there, and, in time, Wesley’s influence was to be found in Wales as well.
This influence continues to the present and has, in large measure, been responsible for the decline of church life in the United Kingdom. That Wesley’s influence continues to the present is evident by a comparison of what Wesley considered to be non-negotiables in his method of evangelism and current practices in these countries. During the course of his work, all of which was conducted within the Church of England, Wesley was frequently asked why he did not separate from the established church. His response was that he wanted to live in harmony with the church in which he had been born, baptized, and ordained, but that to continue in the church required that he be permitted to teach inward and present salvation by faith in Christ, to preach in houses and the open air, to maintain the church political structure of Methodism (within the Church of England), and to continue lay preaching. As long as the established church permitted him to practice these things, he would remain in it.
If one considers that Wesley meant something quite different from “inward and present salvation by faith in Christ” than a Calvinist (as we shall see), one can compare these non-negotiables with the state of evangelical religion in the British Isles today and note with ease the imprint of Wesley. Lay preaching, for example, in spite of Romans 10:14, 15, is widely practiced throughout the British Isles, even by evangelicals and those who claim to be Reformed.
But it was the doctrine of Wesley that had the most significant impact on England.
Wesley’s Mysticism
In the survey of Wesley’s life that appeared in earlier articles, it became evident that Wesley was deeply influenced by mysticism, both the mysticism of the Middle Ages and the mystical teachings in some English writers. Many different mystical influences directed his thinking in his formative years. While later in life he abandoned some of mysticism’s teachings, he continued to be mystically inclined. Robert G. Tuttle, Jr., in his book, Mysticism in the Wesleyan Tradition, speaks of the fact that mysticism has remained an important part of Methodist theology. And it is possible to distinguish between the Arminianism of the Remonstrants in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries as rationalistic Arminians, while Wesley’s Arminianism could be called a mystical Arminianism.
That Wesley’s Arminianism was directly affected by his mysticism is due to an inner relationship between the two. Mysticism emphasizes direct and personal union with God. As I noted earlier, Tuttle points out that mysticism tends to bypass the cross of Jesus Christ, because, in its determination to be led directly to God, it does not emphasize sufficiently Christ as the Mediator between God and His people.
Mysticism influenced Wesley’s thinking in different ways. In the first place, Wesley was actually quite uninterested in doctrine. His biographer Vulliamy points out that Wesley did not want doctrinal formulation. Today he would be among those who boast of having “no creed by Christ.” Yet, says Vulliamy, he became very angry when anyone disagreed with him.
The doctrines of Scripture all have their center and focal point in the cross of Jesus Christ. And insofar as Wesley’s mysticism tended to emphasize direct union with God, it denigrated the cross; and that denigration of the cross led to a disinterest in doctrine.
In the second place, Wesley’s mysticism led to an over-emphasis on the inner life. This error is actually the opposite of doctrinal disinterest: all that counts in the Christian life is one’s relationship to God. Doctrine is unimportant. It does not matter what a man believes; all that counts is his relationship to God.
In the third place, Wesley’s mysticism led directly to his Arminianism. Wesley did not teach, although he understood well, that all our salvation is only in the cross of Jesus Christ. The error of not giving the cross its full due leads to an emphasis on human effort that denies the cardinal doctrine of sovereign grace.
Finally, Wesley’s mysticism led him to approve of revivals.
Wesley and Revivals
The narratives of Wesley’s life call attention to the fact that, at least in the early part of his open-air ministry, his preaching was frequently accompanied by the strange behavior that is characteristic of revivals, and is evidence, so it is said, of special outpourings of the Holy Spirit. Wesley himself did not, apparently, give a lot of emphasis to these special outpourings of the Spirit, and later in his ministry they ceased. Yet the entire work of Wesley is frequently called The Wesleyan Revival, and George Whitefield’s work in New England, along with that of Jonathan Edwards, has become known as The New England Revival. It is on this basis and on the basis of other “revivals” in the British Isles and in America that evangelicals, some of whom claim to be Reformed, still are busy praying for revival and see revival as the only hope of the church.
These special outpourings of the Spirit that men call revival are generally characterized by such severe conviction of sin that the agonies of the consciousness of sin lead to bizarre behavior. And the deliverance from conviction of sin leads to such joy in the Lord that it too is manifested in unusual and strange conduct. An example of such an occurrence is described by Vulliamy in his biography. It took place during the preaching of one of Wesley’s colleagues.
Inside the church at Everton, while Berridge was preaching or conducting his service, some of the people fainted and fell quietly on the floor, others roared and screamed, sinking down in horrible contortions; at one moment they felt themselves dropping into the blazing cavity of hell, and at the next, they were rising in ecstasies of joy and gratitude. Those who were less affected stood on the seats of the pews in order to see the disturbed congregation. The noise was incredible. Rustic boots hammered against the boards, broke the benches and split the sides of the pews. Children set up a shrill wailing. Women shrieked horribly, clapped their hands, or fell upon each other’s necks. Some uttered short ejaculations of praise, and others shouted in wild triumph. Below the louder sounds there was all the while a noise of hard breathing, as of men half strangled and gasping for life. And above all the appalling din could be heard the powerful voice of Berridge, praying and preaching and calling on sinners, louder and more unmelodious, and louder still, until no voice, no human head or heart, could bear the strain any longer, and he walked out through the stricken multitude.
Berridge walked from the church to the vicarage, and there the work was continued. People were carried into the house like casualties from the scene of some hideous disaster. Children raved and struggled in passages. It was
observed by a witness that “almost all on whom God laid His hand turned either very red or almost black.” Some laughed foolishly “with extreme joy,” tears of inexpressible emotion running down their pale, radiant faces.
Stories of such conduct can be found in any history of revivals, as strange and as unwelcome as they are. They are supposed to be the manifestations of conversion on a grand scale. It is not my purpose to criticize the whole concept of revivals: their wrong view of conversion, their mysticism with its emphasis on feeling, their false description of the work of conversion and salvation in the hearts of God’s people, their wrong exegesis in making the biblical basis of revivals the national conversions of Israel in the Old Testament, and their failure to take into account God’s federal and organic dealings with men in the line of generations. It is more than passing strange that people who claim to be Reformed can continue to pray for such modern-day revivals as was supposed to have taken place in the past.
Wesley’s Arminianism
Although Wesley claimed to be uninterested in doctrine, he nevertheless was sufficiently interested to preach and teach a thorough-going Arminianism, and to pour out his spite and hatred of Calvinistic doctrines of grace. He despised election and reprobation and blasphemed it and the God who determined both. How it was possible for George Whitefield to continue to associate with such a man has got to be indicative of Whitefield’s own weakness. Wesley repudiated utterly the truth that Christ died only for His elect people, and he spoke of particular redemption as a failure of the cross. He vitiated the doctrine of irresistible grace, which he claimed to maintain, by balancing all salvation on the needle-point of man’s free will.
The evidences of his Arminianism are numerous.
In his controversies with Howell Harris, George Whitefield, and Augustus Toplady, he showed a bitter antagonism against the truth of the gospel and of God’s sovereign and particular grace. After the controversy with Toplady, he felt compelled to publish a Manifesto.
We have leaned too much towards Calvinism. Wherein?
With regard to man’s faithfulness. Our Lord Himself taught us to use this expression….
With regard to working for life. This also our Lord has expressly commanded us….
We have received it as a maxim, that “a man is to do nothing in order to justification.” Nothing can be more false. Whoever desires to find favour with God should “cease from evil and learn to do well.”
Review the whole affair: Who of us is now accepted of God? He that now believes in Christ with a loving and obedient heart.
As to merit itself, of which we have been so dreadfully afraid; we are rewarded “according to our works,” yea, “because of our works.” How does this differ from for the sake of our works? And how differs this from sendum merita operum? as our works deserve? Can you split this hair? I doubt I cannot (that is: I have no doubt I cannot, HH).
The grand objection to one of the preceding propositions is drawn from matter of fact. God does in fact justify those who, by their own confession, neither feared God nor wrought righteousness. Is this an exception to the general rule? It is a doubt, God makes any exception at all. But how are we sure that the person in question never did fear God and work righteousness? His own saying so is no proof; for we know how all that are convinced of sin undervalue themselves in every respect.
Does not talking of a justified or sanctified state tend to mislead men? Almost naturally leading them to trust in what was done in one moment? Whereas we are every hour and every moment pleasing or displeasing to God according to our works; according to the whole of our inward tempers and our outward behaviour.
Nothing could be clearer that Wesley put sanctification before justification; that he made sanctification dependent upon the human will, that man is able not only to do good works but to merit by them, and that therefore the whole of man’s salvation turned on man’s own choice.
He maintained as well the totally Arminian doctrines of a universal atonement, an atoning sacrifice of our Lord which only made salvation available to those who would believe in Christ. He defined the gospel, in close connection with his erroneous views of the atonement, as an expression of God’s willingness to save all men. He believed that those who never heard the gospel could be saved by the proper use of what natural light they possessed. Although giving the doctrine his own peculiar twist, he also taught Perfectionism, that is, that the sinner can attain perfection in this life.
Wesley regarded the religious consciousness as advancing from a lower to a higher condition; he believed in a law of ascending evolution, with a corresponding ascending scale of moral values and responsibilities. It is possible, while in the body, to reach a state of Christian perfection; but not of sinless perfection, for that would make of no account the sacrifice of Christ. “By perfection,” said Wesley, “I mean perfect love, or the loving of God with all our heart, so as to rejoice evermore, to pray without ceasing, and in everything to give thanks. I am convinced every believer may attain this; yet I do not say he is in a state of damnation or under the curse of God till he does attain. No, he is in a state of grace, and in favour with God, as long as he believes.”
This is a remarkable statement. The only need we have for the cross of Christ, according to Wesley, is for the sins that remain after we have attained Christian perfection. That does not leave much for Christ to do.
And yet Wesley has cast a long shadow. His views are held everywhere. What is so troubling is that Wesley is honored by those who profess to be Calvinists, but who ignore that Wesley hated Calvinism with his whole being. What is so troubling is that Wesley’s doctrine of justification by works is being taught today by many within Reformed and Presbyterian churches. How few they be who hold to the truth of God’s great grace in Jesus Christ given to us poor sinners, that God Himself may receive all the glory for the riches of His sovereign mercy and love.