Rev. Daniel Holstege, pastor of the Wingham PRC in Wingham, Ontario, Canada

Rumblings on the Canadian-American fault line of the CRC

To one who is not too familiar with the history of the Christian Reformed Church in Canada, like myself, the lead article in a recent issue of the Canadian-based periodical Christian Courier came as a bit of a surprise: “Dreaming of a Canadian Synod: New group calls for the end of Christian Reformed Church binationalism.”1 What is “binationalism”? The basic idea is that the Christian Reformed Church in North America (CRCNA) is a denomination that spans two nations, the United States and Canada. Many denominations have fraternal relationships with churches in other nations. But few denominations actually stretch across national borders. According to their website, the Christian Reformed Church has a little over a thousand churches, 75% of which are in the United States and 25% of which are in Canada. But a group of leaders on the Canadian side recently banded together in the hope of possibly seceding from the Americans and starting a new denomination. If that would happen, it would reduce the size of the Christian Reformed Church significantly.

Angela Reitsma Bick, a writer for Christian Courier, interviewed John Vanderstoep, a Christian Reformed pastor in Fergus, Ontario and leader in the new group, in the November 22 (2023) issue of the magazine. When asked about the origin of the group, Vanderstoep an­swered, “Our tentative name is Towards a CRC Cana­da. We are a grassroots organization trying to answer the question, ‘Should the CRC in Canada be our own denomination and what kind?’” Vanderstoep answered a question about the driving factors of this “initiative” by referring to Canada’s unique culture, theology, and ministries. As one example, he said that in the U.S. the native Americans were a mission field, but in Canada, “we’re doing a lot of learning.” What is that supposed to mean, one wonders? Does the pastor not believe that the heathen people who were the original inhabitants of North America were and are the objects of missions? What is it about Canadian culture and theology that makes the heathen no longer need the gospel? Most of the Canadians I know do not share Pastor Vanderstoep’s way of thinking.

Then the big question: “Is everyone in the group LGBTQ affirming?” Ah, now we come to the real is­sue, do we not? Vanderstoep’s answer: “No. That’s a great question, because one objection to our group is ‘this is just another way around the HSR’ (Human Sex­uality Report)…. So yes, there are affirming people in the group; there are non-affirming people in the group. There’s both. We want both. As Canadians that’s a cre­ative tension out of which something can be built.” Re­ally, pastor? Having people in your group who affirm that it is okay to be lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgen­der and people who do not affirm it is a “creative ten­sion out of which something can be built?” I tend to think of creative tension as the kind of thing a thought­ful artist might experience when debating whether to use warm or cool colors to paint a mountain on canvas. When two sides are battling over whether it is a sin for a man to have sex with another man or a woman with another woman, or whether it is okay for a man to be­come a woman or vice versa, you do not call that cre­ative tension but the battle of light versus darkness. Ca­nadian CRC pastors and members who are not LGBT affirming, you ought not to join forces with those who are, for what concord has Christ with Belial, and what communion has light with darkness?

Rather, you ought to take a stand against the rising tide of vile sexual perversion in the world. You ought to hold fast to the truth that homosexuals are sinning and do not need us to affirm their sinful desires and actions, but they need us to call them lovingly and humbly to the cleansing blood of Christ in the way of repentance. I have come to know a few conservative CRC pastors here in southern Ontario who do not share the views of “Towards a CRC Canada.” I asked a couple of them for their thoughts as we had breakfast together. They are convinced that this new movement is primarily made up of liberals who are angry over the CRC synod’s refus­al to budge on calling homosexual activity a sin. They are moving in the direction of exiting the CRC so that they can be an openly LGBT-affirming denomination. It seems that the rumblings on the Canadian-American fault line of the CRC might soon lead to another de­nomination splitting over the issue of human sexuality.

The new “Alliance of Reformed churches”

Moving to the Reformed Church in America (RCA), a new alliance of churches has already separated from that denomination in recent years and calls itself the “Alliance of Reformed Churches” (ARC). According to an article on their website, “The Alliance started with a movement of congregations asking the RCA to provide definitive boundaries to its view of biblical exegesis and understanding of authority. By doing so, the RCA would also set boundaries to its understanding of universalism, interfaith practice, and human sexuality. While human sexuality was most often the focal point of these requests because of cultural trends and national government practices in Canada and the U.S., the core foundation was defining the understanding and boundaries of biblical authority and exegesis in the RCA.”2

The author continues, “On January 1, 2022, the Al­liance moved from its research phase to its launch phase and was born when 43 congregations were released [from the RCA] to become partner congregations. Throughout the spring, summer, and fall of 2022, those 43 congregations would be joined by almost 90 more congregations so that the Alliance expects to have 125+ congregations by the end of 2022.” As of this writing early in 2024, their website shows that they have 158 churches across the United States. The largest clusters are in the areas of northwest Iowa and west Michigan.

In Canada, a related alliance of churches formed on October 18, 2022 called the Reformation Canada Network (RCN).3 They call themselves a new denomi­nation, though they are still waiting for charitable sta­tus in Canada. It appears that almost all of the RCA churches in Canada left the denomination to form the Reformation Canada Network.4 The RCN maintains close ties with the Alliance of Reformed Churches and appears to have left the RCA for the same reasons. In­terestingly, the Canadian RCA’s are more conservative than the Canadian CRC’s on human sexuality, whereas in the United States it appears that the opposite is true, the American RCA’s are by and large more liberal than the American CRC’s.

All of these massive denominational changes hap­pening around us remind us that we live in tumultuous times of apostasy and lawlessness. We can thank God when we see churches holding fast to the truth about human sexuality and resisting the cultural tsunami of the LGBT-affirming movement that looms so large over us today like a black cloud of evil. But we also mourn the widespread apostasy that such separations and the birth of such alliances implies, even as we also recognize with hope that such apostasy is a sign of the approach­ing Christ and end of the world for which we pray daily.

Finally, as we observe the falling away of many and the flight of congregations from their apostatizing de­nominations, we have much cause for thanksgiving to God if we are members of a denomination whose pas­tors preach against all kinds of sexual sin without wa­vering; preach the gospel of forgiveness for sinners of all kinds who flee to the cross of Christ and trust in His cleansing blood alone; and practice what they preach by living chastely and temperately in all respects as hus­bands who are in love with their one wife; a denomi­nation too whose elders admonish and discipline those who walk in sexual sin of any kind and also practice what they preach by living faithfully and humbly in the bond of holy wedlock with their one wife.

Since there is no perfect denomination on the face of the earth, let us take heed to ourselves as we observe the apostasy all around us, lest we also get swept off our feet by the tsunami of the sexual revolution. Let us hold fast to the precious things God has given us and be ready always to reform in the areas where we have become weak or gone astray (semper reformanda). Let us do so in complete and conscious dependence on the grace of God.


1 https://www.christiancourier.ca/dreaming-of-a-canadian-syn¬od/. The Banner also reported on this online on November 17 of last year: https://www.thebanner.org/news/2023/11/groups-sug¬gesting-pathways-for-separation-unity-in-the-crcna.
2 https://arc21.org/blog/origins-a-movement-begins-t9zeg.
3 https://reformationcanada.ca/faqs.
4 See the church statistical data page of the website of the RCA: https://crf.rca.org/public/stats/3908?new-starts=0.