Mr. Brian VanEngen, member of the Hull PRC in Hull, Iowa and a practicing attorney
It is not often that we would think of an article on banking regulations as a topic that would fit in a rubric addressing Church and State religious liberty matters. However, a recent gaffe by the late-night comedy show “Saturday Night Live” recently brought attention to an issue that is of growing concern to Christians. The comedy show, which frequently mocks religious and conservative individuals, often includes a segment called “Weekend Update,” depicting a news report in which the actors portray news reporters and anchors. In a recent episode, the show attempted to mock former President Donald Trump’s use of the term “debanking” in a campaign speech in New Hampshire. The show indicated that the former president had a mental stumble and had made up the term, joking that he may have to take “de-ambulance to see de-doctor.”
Many different sources were quick to point out that “de-banking” is in fact a recognized banking term, and that Saturday Night Live may wish to vet their jokes better before attempting to mock someone. However, the whole incident brought light to an issue that is of growing concern. Debanking, which is sometimes referred to as “derisking,” is the practice of closing a customer’s accounts when the bank perceives that the customer poses a financial, legal, regulatory, or reputational risk to the bank. More traditionally, this practice would be used to eliminate customers that the bank thought might embroil them in legal matters or damage the bank’s reputation by affiliation with seedy businesses engaged in activities such as money laundering, illegal drugs, or prostitution. The concern is that more recently, it appears that this practice is being used to eliminate customers who hold unpopular moral or political views, such as groups with conservative religious and political stances.
Under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, as well as individual state constitutions, citizens have the right to practice their religions as they see fit. The Supreme Court has long held that government can only infringe on these rights if there is a compelling government interest, and any infringement must be narrowly tailored to accomplish a legitimate government purpose.1 The First Amendment also guarantees the right to Free Speech, which allows citizens to express their beliefs without fear of reprisal from the government, with very limited exceptions. Any action of the government to the contrary may be struck down as unconstitutional.
However, the freedoms guaranteed in the First Amendment are freedoms from infringement only by the government, and work to restrain the government, not private businesses. Therefore private businesses can generally limit speech or religious exercise of those with whom they deal. For instance, a business can refuse to print a message that the owners disagree with, as long as they are not discriminating against a protected class, such as members of a certain racial group. As has been discussed in this rubric, the Supreme Court has even held that a Christian baker did not have to bake a cake celebrating a homosexual marriage.2
The problem that the debanking issue highlights is the possibility of the government using regulations to pressure banks or other businesses to take actions against certain religious or political groups. Using this means, the government could work to stifle free speech or limit the free exercise of religion through a business, when it could not do so itself. There is evidence that such government coercion is taking place today.
In today’s world, most of our day-to-day transactions are accomplished through electronic transactions connected with a bank or a credit card issued by a bank. Imagine if your bank were suddenly to terminate your accounts, effectively eliminating your access to your funds to buy groceries, to fill your car with gas, or to purchase airline tickets. An organization that experiences this would not be able to carry out its normal day-to-day functions, effectively shutting it down until other arrangements could be made, new accounts established, and those accounts linked to suppliers as necessary.
This is the scenario experienced by Indigenous Advance Ministries, a Christian non-profit that helps Ugandan widows and children. Bank of America notified the organization that it was closing their deposit and credit card accounts, first stating that “we have determined you’re operating in a business type we have chosen not to service at Bank of America.”3 The bank later indicated that the non-profit “no longer aligns with the bank’s risk tolerance.” The disruption resulted in the organization scrambling to find a new bank, while five employees in Uganda went without a paycheck for an extra week.
A number of religious or conservative organizations have been terminated in similar manner, some with vague explanations, some with more overt reference to their religious or political viewpoints. The Ruth Institute, a Christian non-profit organization, was informed by Wells Fargo that their account was being terminated because it was “affiliated with a product/service that promotes hate, violence, harassment and/or abuse.”4 Heartbeat International, Inc., a pro-life organization, was bluntly informed by its insurer that it’s policy was canceled and that Heartbeat’s stance on legalized abortion precipitated that move.5
The actions of some of these companies may be explained in part by a desire to increase their Environmental, Social, Governance (ESG) score.6 There is increasing demand by activists to rate companies based on these factors, and brokerage firms now list a company’s ESG score among the first items of information about a company. The environmental score is largely based on environmental protection policies, and the social component is based on matters such as civil rights recognition and diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) considerations. Anheuser-Busch recently created a firestorm when they put a transgender man on a can of Bud Light beer, and some suspect the move was intended to raise the company’s ESG score.7 Similarly, a company could raise its ESG score by terminating affiliations to individuals or companies who express disapproval of such lifestyles.
However, it appears that some state and federal government agencies may also be pressuring companies to cut off business ties to conservative and religious organizations. In order to investigate these allegations further, the House Judiciary Committee established a subcommittee known as the Select Subcommittee on the Weaponization of the Federal Government. On March 6, 2024, the Subcommittee released documents that show that the U.S. Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCen) colluded with large banking institutions to monitor their customers to identify domestic threats and shared a list of “hate groups” published by the Institute for Strategic Dialogue (ISD) to help them do so. The ISD includes “Anti-LGBTQ+” as an example of a hate group. South Carolina Senator Tim Scott recently wrote to the Department of the Treasury inquiring about allegations that the FinCen has “urged private financial institutions to surveil customer’s transaction-level data using politically charged search terms.” The terms mentioned were “Trump,” “MAGA,” “Bass ProShops,” “Gander Mountain,” “Cabela’s,” and “Dick’s Sporting Goods”. The institutions were apparently also notified that people purchasing “religious texts” were another heightened risk for extremism.
The National Rifle Association (NRA) brought action against Maria T. Vullo, the Superintendent of the New York Department of Financial Services, alleging that she had encouraged financial institutions to reconsider their relationship with the NRA, and used public investigations and threats of fines to intimidate insurance companies into dropping the NRA as a client.8 The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit sided with Vullo, and the NRA appealed the matter to the Supreme Court. Arguments are scheduled for March 18, 2024. We will wait to see the ruling of the Supreme Court, both for the decision and to see the breadth of the ruling.
By this point, I am sure the reader has also had the words of Revelation 13:16-17 come to mind, where Scripture speaks of the anti-Christian kingdom: “And he causeth all, both small and great, rich and poor, free and bond, to receive a mark in their right hand, or in their foreheads: And that no man might buy or sell, save he that had the mark, or the name of the beast, or the number of his name.”
At this point in history, it is easy to envision a world where those who remain faithful will not be able to buy or sell. We can be comforted by the fact that as we see the events of history unfold, they unfold just as the Lord has revealed they would.
1 See for example Sherbert v. Verner, 374 U.S. 398 (1963); Wiscon¬sin v. Yoder, 406 U.S. 205 (1972).
2 Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission, 584 U.S. ___ ; 138 S. Ct. 1719 (2018).
3 https://adflegal.org/press-release/bank-america-boots-chari¬ty-serving-impoverished-ugandans-under-vague-risk-tolerance
4 https://www.viewpointdiversityscore.org/resources/instances-of-viewpoint-based-de-banking
5 Amicus Brief of Heartbeat International at 1, National Rifle As¬sociation v. Vullo, No. 22-842. (U.S. March 6, 2023).
6 Tedesco, Jeremy and Bahnsen, David L., “How to fight the Polit¬icization of Business.” The National Review, May 17, 2023.
7 McGowan, Jon, “Was Bud Light’s Dylan Mulvaney Decision About ESG?” Forbes, April 12, 2023.
8 National Rifle Association v. Vullo, No. 22-842. (U.S. March 6, 2023).