Rev. Jochen Klautke
pastor of the Confessing Evangelical Reformed Church in Giessen/Germany (BERG) and lecturer in Systematic and Historical Theology at the Academy for Reformed Theology

Regarding [the plan] to collect my writings in volumes, I am quite cool and not at all eager about it because…I would rather see them all devoured. For I acknowledge none of them to be really a book of mine, except the one On the Bound Will and the Catechism.1

With these typically pointed words Martin Luther classified his many works in a letter from 1535. Of all his numerous writings (which, when combined, amount to over 80,000 pages!), he was only truly convinced of the quality of two. Interestingly, one of these two works is On the Bondage of the Will from 1525.

So, while Luther was definitely convinced of the importance and quality of his book, the questions arise: How has the book been perceived by others in the 500 years since then? What influence did it have? And what can we learn from it today?

LIKE-MINDED REFORMERS

Initially, the question of God’s sovereignty and human free will was not the central issue of the Reformation. In the controversy with the Roman Church, the focus was on the relation between the Word of God and ecclesiastical tradition as well as on the question of justification.

The early representatives of the Reformation were in agreement on the issue. So, in 1521 Luther’s close associate Philip Melanchthon (1497-1560) already professed his belief in the bondage of the will in his Loci Communes, the first systematic theology of Protestantism. The topic only became a subject of debate with the publication of Luther’s response to Erasmus’ work On Free Will.

INITIAL OPPOSITION: HUMANISTS AND CATHOLICS

With On the Bondage of the Will, Luther provoked two groups at once.

On the one hand, the Roman Catholic Church objected. Human free will plays an important role in her soteriology. From 1545 onwards, many Catholic officials met at a council in the northern Italian city of Trent to formulate a critical response to the Reformation.2 In their resolutions, they not only contested the Reformation’s convictions on Holy Scripture and justification, but also on the doctrine of the bondage of the will in clear terms: “If anyone says that man’s free will…in no way cooperates in disposing and preparing itself for obtaining the grace of justification; that it cannot refuse its consent…let him be anathema.”3

On the other hand, the humanists around Erasmus felt provoked. The doctrine of the enslaved will simply did not fit in with their optimistic view of humanity and the world. For this reason Erasmus responded to Luther’s reaction in 1526/27. The response is titled: The Hyperaspistes [A Shield-Bearer] of the Diatribe against Luther’s ‘Bondage of the Will’ and comprises two volumes. Other humanists, such as the Spaniard Juan Luis Vives (1492-1540) and the Frenchman Jacques Lefèvre d’Étaples (1455-1536), also defended free will and, despite their own criticism, remained members of the Roman Church (as did Erasmus).

MELANCHTHON AND THE SYNERGISTIC CONTROVERSY

It was Luther’s close ally Philip Melanchthon who brought the controversy into the Reformation camp. Whereas in 1521 he had written in favor of the bondage of the human will, he changed his views in 1535 in a new edition of his Loci Communes. In addition to the work of the Spirit and the power of the Word of God, he now mentioned the will of man as a third “cause of conversion.” In doing so, he significantly softened his view of the bondage of the human will. Luther was not happy at all about his friend’s change of mind, but remained unusually reserved in public.

It was not until after Luther’s death (1546) that a dispute over this question arose among Lutherans in the second half of the 1550s. This controversy in some ways resembled the debates in the Reformed churches in the run-up to the Synod of Dordt. It has gone down in history as the synergistic controversy.

On one side were Luther’s followers, who were called Gnesio-Lutherans. They were led by the Croatian theologian Matthias Flacius (1520-1575) and Luther’s close friend Nikolaus von Amsdorff (1483-1565). They vehemently defended Luther’s doctrine of the bondage of the will. Unfortunately, some of them went too far, equating the bondage of the will with complete passivity on the part of human beings. In an effort to defend Luther’s position, Flacius insisted that man after the fall is purely passive, like a stone or a tree stump.4

On the other side were Melanchthon’s followers, the so-called Philippists. Leading representatives of this school of thought were Viktorin Strigel (1524- 1569) and Johannes Pfeffinger (1493-1573). They defended a certain participation of human (free) will in conversion (that is, synergism). In 1559, Flacius wrote a defense of the bondage of the will under the title Konfutationsbuch (Book of Confutation). When Strigel refused to sign the book, he was imprisoned for several months. The debate about free will had now become not only theological but also political.

In 1560, a public disputation organized by the Saxon elector took place in the city of Weimar, without the question really being resolved. It was not until the formulation of the Formula of Concord in 1577, the latest Lutheran confession in terms of time, that the waves could be largely smoothed.

THE FORMULA OF CONCORD: THE LUTHERAN CONFESSION ON THE BOUND WILL

In its first two articles, the Formula of Concord professes Luther’s view of the enslaved will, thereby refuting Melanchthon and his followers. So, the rejection of the free will of natural human beings is equally part of both the Lutheran and Reformed confessions. And yet the formulations of the Formula of Concord on the sovereignty of God (Art. 11) are significantly more cautious and weaker than the formulations of the Canons of Dordt or the Westminster Confession—and also weaker than Luther’s words in On the Bondage of the Will.

This contributed to Luther’s book being increasingly pushed into the background in German-speaking countries. The Reformed were clearly in the minority compared to Lutherans and Catholics, and had been harshly criticized by Luther because of their position on the Lord’s Supper. Although they appreciated Luther as a reformer, his writings had little influence among German-speaking Reformed Christians. The Canons of Dordt also had little influence in Germany, while the Heidelberg Catechism (the dominant Reformed confession in German-speaking countries) only touches on the question of free will in passing.

FURTHER DEVELOPMENTS

From the seventeenth century onwards, other issues dominated among Lutherans. The confessional “orthodox” emphasized questions relating to justification, the doctrine of Christ, and the Lord’s Supper. The other schools of thought within Lutheranism, Pietism and the Enlightenment, led to a fundamental shift away from the confessions in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Both movements focused on the human subject, so that the bondage of the will was either denied or at least hardly emphasized.

Thus, the work receded further into the background. Other works by Luther, such as On the Freedom of a Christian or his commentary on Galatians, are today considered by the public to be Luther’s central writings. And yet, time and again, there were theologians who rediscovered Luther’s work in the centuries following the Reformation.

One example of this is the Lutheran theologian Hans Joachim Iwand (1899-1960). While being imprisoned by the Nazis, he wrote in 1938 about On the Bondage of the Will, “Anyone who does not put this book down with the realization that protestant theology stands or falls with this doctrine of the bound will has read it in vain.”5

Even today, the work has not been forgotten in Germany. In 2016 it was republished in modernized German. It is interesting to note that it is often not Lutherans who appreciate it. The German reissue was published by a Baptist publishing house. The English editions were translated and edited by Anglicans Henry Cole and J. I. Packer6, while the Dutch editions were published by Reformed publishing houses.

WHAT IS THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE BOOK FOR TODAY?

On the Bondage of the Will is not an easy read. Over the past five centuries, numerous books on the question of free will have been published that are more systematically structured and argue in a more comprehensible way. And yet the book is still of fundamental importance today.

For many Protestants, the defining feature of the Reformation is the importance of the Word of God (sola scriptura) and justification by faith alone (sola fide). This is, of course, entirely accurate. But the fact that Luther described On the Bondage of the Will as one of his most important works and that the Catholic Council of Trent also defended free will so vehemently shows that the question of free will was also one of the central issues of the Reformation period. Today’s Protestantism, which is often characterized by synergism, is much closer to the Catholic position on the question of free will than to the Reformation position of Luther, Calvin, and both the Lutheran and Reformed confessions. Of course, this in itself does not prove the truth of the bondage of the human will. But it does make it clear that many Protestants (similar to Melanchthon) deviate from Reformation doctrine on a central point.

SURPRISED BY LUTHER

For many Protestant Christians, the term Calvinism has very negative connotations. Calvin is said to have been a tyrant, and his teachings are said to deny human responsibility. In short, many evangelical Christians consider the doctrine of the bondage of the human will to be an exclusively Reformed doctrine—with the unspoken implication that “all Christians believe in human free will except for the ‘odd’ Calvinists.” In addition, a very negative image of Calvin prevails in secular culture as well.

Time and again, I have seen people express great surprise when they learn that there were no significant differences between Calvin’s and Luther’s views on free will. As negative as the image of Calvin often is, Protestant Christians generally have a very positive image of Luther (even if they are hardly familiar with his actual theology). So, if you want to gently introduce Christians to the doctrine of God’s sovereignty, it can be very helpful to start with Luther and make it clear that the doctrines of grace are not only Reformed but one of the central truths that were rediscovered throughout the Reformation.

LUTHER’S LEGACY

Luther was aware of the value of his book—perhaps because he sensed that its message would be repeatedly attacked not only by Catholics but also by his own followers. This may have been the reason why—in the same year as Melanchthon’s fatal reversal (1535)— Luther demanded the survival of On the Bondage of the Will. And also in the Catechism, the other book that Luther wanted to survive, he professed this truth with marvelous words:

I believe that I cannot by my own reason or strength believe in Jesus Christ, my Lord, or come to Him; but the Holy Spirit has called me by the Gospel, enlightened me with His gifts, sanctified and kept me in the true faith. In the same way He calls, gathers, enlightens, and sanctifies the whole Christian church on earth, and keeps it with Jesus Christ in the one true faith.… This is most certainly true.7


1 Martin Luther. Luther’s Works, Volume 50: Letters III. Ed. Gottfried G. Krodel (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1975), 172- 173.
2 Despite the clear words of the Council of Trent, there were repeated debates within Roman Catholicism in the following centuries about human free will. The Dutch Catholic Michel de Bay (1513-1589) argued in favor of the bondage of the will and was condemned for this in 1567 by Pope Pius V for deviating from the Council’s decisions. Several decades later, the controversy erupted again when the Spanish Jesuit Luis de Molina (1535-1600) was contradicted for his defense of free will by Domingo Báñez (1528-1604) and later by the Dutchman Cornelius Jansen (1585-1638). The Catholics who opposed the decisions of the Council had arrived at their position less through influences of the Reformation and more through the study of Augustine.
3 Council of Trent, Session VI, Canon VI.
4 This formulation was considered too radical not only by most Lutherans, but also by the Reformed. The Canons of Dordt teach (3/4, 16): “But as man by the fall did not cease to be a creature endowed with understanding and will, nor did sin which pervaded the whole race of mankind deprive him of the human nature, but brought upon him depravity and spiritual death; so also this grace of regeneration does not treat men as senseless stocks and blocks, nor takes away their will and its properties, neither does violence thereto,” And the Second Helvetic Confession states (Art. 9.2): “To be sure, his [man’s] reason was not taken from him, nor was he deprived of will, and he was not entirely changed into a stone or a tree. But they were so altered and weakened that they can no longer do what they could before the fall. Emphasis added.
5 Hans Joachim Iwand, Theologische Einführung in Martin Luthers Schrift De servo arbitrio (Munich, 1939), 289.
6 Martin Luther on the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will, translated by Henry Cole. London 1823. Martin Luther on the Bondage of the Will: A New Translation of De Servo Arbitrio (1525), Martin Luther’s Reply to Erasmus of Rotterdam, translated by J.I. Packer & O.R. Johnston. Old Tappan, NJ, 1957.
7 Martin Luther, Luther’s Small Catechism (St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House), 2019, 11.