With a little good will (I mean by good will the will to enter into the material and essential meaning of the protest of the protestant) the synod would not have adopted the following paragraph of its answer: graph of its answer:

“The protest denies what is taught in the Canons of Dordt, II, 5, in the following passage quoted from 2, B:

“‘We deny that grace of salvation is an offer to anyone, but we accept as scriptural that grace of sal­vation is the glad tiding of promise gives and deliv­ered to God’s own elect and them only.’

“Your committee draws particular attention to the positive definition of grace or salvation given in the last clause according to which the glad tiding of prom­ise is given and delivered only to God’s own elect, and to them only. But the Canons state:

“. . . .which promise ought to be declared and published to all nations and to all persons promiscuous­ly and without distinction, to whom God out of his good pleasure sends the gospel (II, art. 5).”

I claim:

  1. That the committee that composed this answer does not represent the true meaning of the protestant in this paragraph.
  2. That, although the wording of the protest left room for the committee to misinterpret the protest as they did, yet, with a little good will (as above) they could very well have discovered the true meaning of the protestant.
  3. That the fact that the committee quotes the article of the Canons only in part leaves the impression that they also really understood the meaning of the protestant, for the first half of the article, which the committee did not choose to quote, would exactly jus­tify the protestant if his words are interpreted cor­rectly.

Let me explain.

The meaning of the protestant’s words is surely not, that the gospel is preached by men only to the elect. To maintain this would be sheer foolishness. Who would deny that the gospel is and must be preached to men promiscuously? Yet, that is the in­terpretation the committee places upon the words of the protestant. They make a fool of the protestant! An utter fool! This surely’ is no proof of good will. The committee was not very serious. They were not very willing to understand the protest rightly and enter into the real point at issue. The committee also knew very well, that the point as they state it never had been the point at issue between the defenders and the antagonists of the Three Points.

Now, it is true that to anyone that is none too will­ing to understand the words of the protest correctly the wording gave occasion to the interpretation the committee offered. “Grace or salvation is the glad tiding of promise given and delivered to God’s own elect and to them only”. Such is the wording of the protest. The interpretation is apparently possible: the gospel is preached only to the elect. And the committee, not intentionally distorting the meaning of the protest, yet, not any too willing to enter into the question at issue, made use of the occasion. Yet, especially in view of the fact that such an interpretation would presuppose the protestant to be an utter fool, the com­mittee could very well have discovered the true mean­ing of the protestant’s words. There is a contrast in the paragraph of the protest. The contrast is: Grace or salvation is no offer but it is the glad tiding of prom­ise given and delivered to the elect only.

The subject, therefore is: grace or salvation.

The sense of the clause: “grace or salvation is no offer” is, of course: grace or salvation is not realized, effected by an offer on the part of God which must be accepted by man.

The contrast demands that the second clause be interpreted as meaning: grace or salvation is the glad tiding of promise given by God and delivered by God efficaciously to the elect only.

The question, therefore, is not at all to whom the gospel ought to be preached by men.

On the contrary, the question is: what is grace or salvation? How is it effected?

And the answer is: not as an offer, neither by means of an offer on the part of God; but by means of the glad tiding of a promise which promises something to the elect only and which God delivers to none other than the elect. Thus understood (and this was very evidently the meaning of the protestant) it states the truth and nothing but the truth. It is the truth which the committee could not have gainsaid, but which is, indeed, denied by the First Point of 1924.

It is true, that God promises in all His Word salva­tion only to the elect. He swears by Himself that He shall realize the promise to the elect, the heirs of the promise, Heb. 6:16-18. And nowhere does He promise anything at all to the reprobate ungodly. The contents of the promise of the gospel is always such that it per­tains only to the elect and to none other. Hence, I can surely say that salvation is no general offer, but the glad tidings of promise given only to the elect.

It is also true that this glad tiding of promise is (not preached by men but) delivered by God only to the elect. In the first place because the contents of the promise is always such that it pertains to the elect only. But in the second place, too, because this promise is not offered but efficaciously delivered by Him through His irresistible grace to the elect only, so that they receive and embrace the promise.

That is what the protestant meant.

And he did not only mean this, but to anyone that will carefully read his words and has the good will correctly to interpret them, his words also convey that meaning and do not convey the meaning the committee imposed on his words. It was not necessary to make of the protestant a fool.

And now the quotation the committee offers from the Canons.

To say the least it looks suspicious that they quote only the last half of that article.

The committee that served the synod of 1924 with their advice in regard to this matter acted similarly with respect to Canons III, IV, 4. And the circum­stances are similar too. Had the committee of 1924 quoted the entire article, they would have proved the exact opposite from that which they intended to prove by quoting only the first half. And had the committee that composed the answer to the protest we are now discussing, offered the entire article from which they quote only the latter half, they would have justified the protestant.

How does the first half of the article read? As follows:

“Moreover, the promise of the gospel is that whosoever believeth in Christ crucified, shall not perish but have everlasting life”.

What is the promise of the gospel?

Deliverance from eternal destruction and the gift of everlasting life.

To whom does the promise pertain?

To them that believe in Christ crucified.

Who are they that believe?

The elect.

To whom, then, is the glad tiding of promise given by God ? To the elect and to them only.

The protestant was right. The committee and the synod ought to have justified him.

And they should have retracted the First Point as unreformed.