The Three Points According to Dr. Klooster, as we have seen before, the strongest Scriptural proof in support of the first point of the notorious “Three Points” is to be found in Luke 6:35, 36. We have already discussed this passage in connection with the similar text inMatthew 5.
We particularly explained the love of our enemies to which we are enjoined in these passages.
But certainly, neither of these texts teach common grace, that is, a grace of God to the wicked reprobate. To be sure, God causes His sun to shine upon all, the righteous and the wicked alike, and He sends rain upon the just and the unjust. No one denies this. But the question is whether the wicked receive grace in this rain and sunshine. If they do, then they will employ these temporal gifts, together with all things to the glory of God and with thanksgiving. And then all things will turn to their salvation. If they do not receive the rain and the sunshine in the grace of God, they will use all these temporal things in the service of sin and receive greater damnation.
Such is the teaching of Scripture throughout.
Now we must write just a few words yet about the text in Luke 6.
This passage plainly speaks of the fact that God is kind to the unthankful and evil. Is not this then “common grace”? Are not the reprobate wicked included in the unthankful and evil and is not God, therefore, kind and gracious and merciful to them as well as to the righteous? In answer to this question, I must once more refer you to the overwhelming testimony of Scripture to the contrary: God curses and is angry with the wicked every day. Hence, the text in Luke G cannot possibly teach this, for the Bible does not contradict itself. Now, God is surely kind to the unthankful and evil, but not to all of them, not to the ungodly reprobate, as is the teaching of the “First Point,” but only to His own elect. That this is true is evident even from the immediate context of this passage as we have already pointed out. God’s people belong, by nature, to the unthankful and evil. And even after they have been regenerated and called they are still often revealing the spirit of unthankfulness and sin. But that God is kind and gracious to the unthankful and evil by no means implies that He is kind to all of them without exception.
However, the “First Point” does not confine itself to what is usually called common grace, but it lapses into the error of the Arminian theory of general grace when it speaks of the “general offer of the gospel” as grace to all that hear the preaching of the gospel. This is, evidently, the intent when as the grounds for the “First Point” appeal is made to the texts in Ezekiel 33:11 andEzekiel 18:23; and also to the Canons of Dordrecht, III, IV, 8, 9.
Dr. Klooster does not discuss the above mentioned texts from Ezekiel: he merely mentions them. And as to the references from the Canons he has this to say:
“The Synodical decision seeks support for the well-meant offer of the gospel by an appeal to the Canons of Dordt. The Canons (III, IV, 8, 9) are indeed quite explicit in asserting the doctrine of the well-meant gospel call, for they say: ‘As many as are called by the gospel are unfeignedly called. But I do not think the Canons say much concerning the precise point at issue, namely, whether this well-meant offer of the gospel is evidence of an attitude of favor on God’s part to mankind in general. Perhaps the statement that ‘God calls men by the gospel and confers upon them various gifts’ (III, IV, 9) comes closest to the point at issue.”
All this does not leave the impression of certainty on the part of Klooster. Notice that he writes, not that the Synodical decision actually supports, but that it “seekssupport for the well-meant offer of the gospel.” Again, he writes: “I do not think the Canons say much concerning the precise point at issue.” I ask: do they say anything at all concerning this point? I deny this. Once more, he writes, not that the statement in Canons III, IV, 9 proves the point, but that “perhaps it comesclosest to the point at issue.” Why all this weak and doubtful language? Is it proper to build doctrines of the church on the basis of such dubious language and then cast faithful Reformed ministers out of the church, an act for which also Klooster assumes responsibility to this very day?
My answer to this question is: absolutely not!
However, the chief question that concerns us here is whether it is true that the preaching of the gospel is grace and intended to be grace on the part of God to all that hear this preaching. That this is the teaching of the “First Point” there can be no doubt. Its main intention is to defend the doctrine of so-called common grace, that is, the doctrine that God is gracious to all men, the righteous and wicked alike. Hence, when in this connection it mentions the preaching of the gospel, it teaches that in the preaching God is graciously inclined to and bestows grace upon all the hearers.
It may be considered strange that the Synod of 1924 adduced this as a proof for the theory of “common grace.” For, to be sure, rain and sunshine and all the other things in this present time are, indeed, common to all men; but this cannot be said of the preaching of the gospel which throughout the ages has come to comparatively few and that, too, both according to Scripture and the Confessions, only to those to whom God in His good pleasure sends the gospel. How, then, can the preaching of the gospel be “common grace”? And how could the Synod of 1924 possibly come to this conclusion? The only possible answer is: 1. The Synod felt that in order to maintain the doctrine of “common grace” as a Reformed doctrine and to condemn those that denied it, it must adduce proof from the Reformed Confessions; 2. The Confessions, however, do not speak of “common grace” at all in the sense that God is gracious to all men, wicked and righteous alike, through the things which He bestows on them in this present time; 3. However, it does speak of the general preaching of the gospel and the Synod adduced this as a proof that God is gracious to all the hearers, which, by the way, is neither Scriptural nor Confessional. The Scriptural and Reformed truth is quite different. According to it, God loved and chose unto eternal life and glory a people in Christ Jesus their Lord and that, too, in distinction from the reprobate. In behalf of the elect God sent His Son in the likeness of sinful flesh; He suffered and died for their sin, arose to their justification, and is now exalted at the right hand of God. Moreover, He received the Spirit and by that Spirit He enters into and dwells in the hearts of all the elect, regenerating them and calling them efficaciously through the preaching of the gospel. To them, that is, to the elect, that preaching of the gospel is grace and to them only, while the rest are hardened. By that Spirit and through the preaching of the gospel, the elect are preserved unto eternal life and glory. They can never fall away from grace and be lost. This is the teaching of all the Reformed Confessions and of the whole of Scripture.
—H.H.
Evolution, Long Periods, or Days
In the beginning of my articles on the above mentioned subject (and by the way there are some very excellent articles on the same subject in former Standard Bearers by the Rev. H. Veldman) I maintained that one who supports the theory of long periods and, consequently, of evolution, cannot maintain the infallible inspiration of Genesis 1 and, therefore, of the whole of Scripture.
If in Calvin College this camouflaged theory of evolution is taught, as it is, the inevitable result will be, that the students draw the very logical conclusion thatGenesis 1 is not the infallibly inspired Word of God and that, therefore, the whole of the Bible is not infallibly inspired.
In this contention I was supported by a recent article, an editorial, in The Banner.
The Rev. John Vander Ploeg writes that a student at Calvin Seminary questions the infallibility of Scripture. That student, M. Hoogland, wrote an article inStromata, a paper published monthly by the Calvin Seminary students, under the title “Infallibility Questioned.” The article, according to Rev. Vander Ploeg, is an “attempt to prove that the Bible is not infallible.” He quotes from the article of Hoogland as follows:
“By way of conclusion and clarification it might be said that the purpose here has not been to prove that there are as a matter of fact errors in Scripture so much as it has been to suggest that there is no need for us to assume at all costs that the Scriptures are ‘infallible.’ The writers of our confessional standards make no reference to infallibility in the sense in which it has come to be used by conservative theologians today. In view of the relativity which the meanings of words so often display, it may not be too far-fetched to say that it even attests to the divine wisdom that in all of the many claims to inspiration, no claim is made to ‘infallibility.'”
And Vander Ploeg also quotes from the Calvin College Chimes in which a certain William Brown highly praises Hoogland’s article and concludes by writing: “Hoogland has had the good sense to question a doctrine that has become an idol of the Evangelical Tribe.”
It is not my purpose to criticize the above quotations. This is not necessary for our readers. Besides, the Rev. Vander Ploeg promises to write more about the subject. My purpose is to show the connection between the theory of evolution or long periods instead of days and the denial of the infallibility of Holy Writ. How can one maintain the infallible inspiration of Gen. 1-3and at the same time believe that the days of creation were millions or billions of years? And if the infallibility of Gen. 1-3 is denied, one can no longer maintain the infallible inspiration of the rest of the Bible. Hence, I am not surprised that if the theory of evolution or that of long periods (which, to my mind is the same thing) is taught at Calvin College, the students at the seminary deny the infallibility of Scripture.
I wish to make one more remark before I continue my discussion of the days of the creation week.
I believe that I made the remark in one of my articles that Darwinism is dead. But from an article inChristianity Today, Jan. 5, 1959, it appears that this is not quite true. Darwinism is now a hundred years old and this fact was the occasion of the publication of a book entitled A Century of Darwin. The writer of this article, Philip E. Hughes, reviews this book and he writes that “the editor claims this book shows that, so far from being dead, Darwinism is respectable.” The writer, Hughes, adds: “Whether it is right is another question; and perhaps it would be unkind to suggest that there is no place more respectable than a cemetery!” According to the writer, moreover, “The effect of the whole is neither massive nor impressive.” And the reason for this is that the structure of Darwinism is based on an “unverifiable assumption preached as an infallible dogma.”
But the dogma of “natural selection” is still maintained. It is, according to one of the authors of the above mentioned book, the great force “through which operation organic life in the multiplicity of all its forms has come into existence.” And Mr. Hughes adds: “Indeed, it might perhaps better be described as the new god which has supplanted the God of Scripture to whose creative activity the whole natural order used to be attributed—and still is by those who have been renewed in knowledge after the image of him that created them” (Col. 3:10).
I will not discuss the article at length. It certainly is worth reading especially by students who, perhaps, entertain the false notion that the different species developed from one another. But I will conclude by quoting the closing paragraph of the article:
“It is the assumption unsupported and unsupportable by factual evidence and indeed contrary to scientific knowledge, that life originated from lifeless matter and has, in all its variety and complexity, evolved ultimately from the simplest unicellular organism. With its dogmas, myths, and creedal mystiques, modern Darwinism quite certainly qualifies for a place in current religious thought.”
It is my contention that those who make of the creation days of Gen. 1 long periods of billions of years must come to the conclusion that all things have evolved from a simple and single cell, that the species evolved from one-another, and that life originated from lifeless matter. To be sure, they will say that all this took place under the providence of God, but providence is not creation and neither is evolution.
—H.H.
The Question About Church Visitation
About this subject I received a question from the elders of Classis East to be answered on their meeting of Jan. 6. The question was: “What is the origin and history of. Art. 44 of the Church Order, and how must it be applied.” And now my own consistory asked me to publish the remarks I made in answer to the above question. You understand, of course, that I spoke only from notes. And it is from these notes that I will attempt to reproduce what I said at the meeting of the elders as nearly as possible.
More than once the Church Order speaks of ecclesiastical deputies that are assigned a certain task whether by the Classis or by the Synod. To these also belong the deputies that are mentioned in Art. 44 and which are known as Church Visitors.
You ask me, first of all, what is the origin of this article. To this I would reply that no specific origin of the custom of appointing church visitors can be designated. In general, however, I would say the origin must be found in the very nature of the church connection. The Reformed Churches do not lead a separate existence as individual churches but constitute a denomination. Although, to be sure, each congregation has its own consistory as its governing body, yet the churches are united on the basis of the Confessions and the Church Order. They have many things in common. It stands to reason, therefore, that seeing they have many common interests, they are also interested in one another’s wellbeing and pay attention to one another. And this may be regarded as the origin of the custom of appointing church visitors and of Art. 44 of the Church Order.
As to the history of this article I may say the following.
We all know, of course, that it was composed, almost in its present form, and adopted by the Synod of Dordrecht in 1618-19. It took the place of an article about church visitation that was added to, the Church Order by the General Synod of The Hague in 1586. Before this date nothing can be found about church visitation in the older editions of the Church Order.
This does not mean, however, that the matter itself was entirely strange to the churches before this time. As we said, it lies in the nature of the church connection in the Reformed Churches that they are interested in and pay attention to one another. Often this was done also by specific and intentional investigation. Thus there was already an act concerning church visitation in the province of North Holland in 1575. Also in the churches of North Holland and Zeeland it was, for that very reason, decided that the classical meetings should be held in all the different places of the Classis. It was thought that, in this way, the Classis would be in a position to learn as much as possible about the condition of the various churches.
This, of course, proved quite insufficient especially in view of the fact that, even at that time, many evils already existed in the churches both in regard to doctrine and life: Discipline was not exercised and the life of the churches was often very lax. Hence, in 1579 a gravamen or proposition was offered to the Particular Synod of South Holland requesting that each Particular Synod and Classis appoint deputies with the calling to take care of all cases that would occur between meetings and also to see to it that every one in the consistories execute his office faithfully. This proposition was not treated at the time because it was not handed in in time. But it shows that the need for church visitation was felt. A similar proposition was brought to the attention of the Synod of Middelburg in 1581. This, however, was rejected chiefly because the Synod was afraid of introducing hierarchy in the churches.
The General Synod of The Hague, however, held in 1586, introduced a rather strong article about church visitation in the Church Order, and also added some guiding principles for the church visitors that would be appointed by the Classes. The guiding principles were the following (my information I have from Rutgers’Kerkelijke Adviezen, Vol. I, p. 354 ff.):
1. They shall occasionally listen to the sermons of the minister, not only to find out whether he is pure in doctrine, but also whether he preaches in such a way that the sermons can be for the benefit and edification of the congregation. They shall further investigate whether the minister is diligent in the reading and study of Scripture, and finally, whether the minister makes use of the accepted forms for baptism and other ceremonies.
2. They shall carefully and with courtesy attempt to find out with the elders and deacons-of the church in which the minister serves, or even from the members of the church, whether the minister is faithful in edifying the church, whether he exercises Christian discipline, and whether to that end the ecclesiastical gatherings are held.
3. They shall also have oversight over the life and walk of the minister, and find out whether there are any quarrels and disunity in the congregation or other disorders that are detrimental to the life of the congregation and that ought to be removed as quickly as possible.
4. Finally, if with the members of the consistory there are found any faults with respect to the above mentioned instances, they shall first admonish them privately unto improvement and also help them unto that end, and if this is of no avail they shall report the matter to Classis.
From these principles we learn, first of all, that the church visitors were chiefly concerned with the work and walk of the minister, although the rest of the consistory were, of course, not excluded. Secondly, we also receive the impression that the church visitors were given considerable power even though it was only the power of advice. We may also learn something from this in our day. It would be a good thing, for instance, especially in some cases, as in 1952-53, that the church visitors visit the services to listen to the sermon of the minister (without his knowing that they are coming or that they are present) to see whether he preaches the Word of God to the edification of the congregation. There certainly can be no reasonable objection to this whatever. And the Synod of The Hague 1586 considered this quite proper. As it is today, church visitation is often nothing but a “wassen neus.”
But about this presently.
Thus, finally, the Synod of Dordrecht, 1618-19, adopted article 44 and inserted it in the Church Order.
And the question is: how must this article be applied and carried out properly.
I will first of all quote the article:
“The classis shall authorize at least two of her oldest, most experienced and most competent ministers to visit all the churches once a year and to take heed whether the minister arid the consistory faithfully perform the duties of their office, adhere to sound doctrine, observe in all things the adopted order, and properly promote as much as lies in them, through word and deed, the upbuilding of the congregation, in particular of the youth, to the end that they may in time fraternally admonish those who have in anything been negligent, and may by their advice and assistance help direct all things to the peace, upbuilding and greatest profit of the churches. And each classis may continue these visitors in service as long as it sees fit, except where the visitors themselves request to be released for the reasons of which the classis shall judge.”
To this article the following decisions were appended (in my talk before the elders I added some remarks, to these decisions which I will now, too, append to each decision):
“1. Each classis shall appoint from her midst at least two ministers and their alternatives.”
Remark: This is stated in Art. 44. Only it weakens the article considerably. The article does not simply speak of the appointment of at least two ministers but emphatically mentions “two of her oldest, most experienced and most competent ministers.” To my mind, this is very important. The fathers did not consider church visitation the work of everybody, not even of every minister. It is, if properly conducted, a most difficult work that requires experience, tact and wisdom as well as strong conviction and clear insight into the truth. For that reason Art. 44 speaks of the oldest, most experienced and competent ministers.
“2. The visitors shall give the congregations at least eight days’ notice of the day and hour of their proposed visit.”
I am glad that this decision speaks of giving notice, not the consistories, but to the congregations. This implies, of course, that also the members of the congregation are interested in church visitation. It implies, too, that the visit of the church visitors be announced from the pulpit so that any member of the congregation that has anything against the minister and his preaching or against the consistory and their functioning in their respective offices, may bring this to the attention of the visitors. As far as I know this announcement is never made from the pulpit, but it should be done nevertheless. It certainly was done in former years according to Rutgers and should be done according to Monsma and Van Dellen. It stands to reason that not everything can be brought by members of the congregation to the attention of the church visitors but only such matters as pertain to the office and walk of the officebearers as, for instance, the preaching of the ministers and the exercise of discipline by the consistory. Suppose, on the one hand that the members of the congregation voice a general complaint that they are not edified by the preaching of the minister, that he preaches the same thing all the time, and that the elders know about it but do nothing about this situation, then I think it is certainly the calling of the members to bring the matter to the attention of the church visitors and of the latter to investigate the matter. In a case like that it would even be proper for the church visitors to ask the minister whether they might see some of his sermons and to listen to some of them. Suppose, on the other hand, that in the congregation there are some chronic complainers for whom the sermons of the ministers are never edifying, let them bring their well-grounded complaint to the church visitors. If they do, and the latter find their complaints without ground, the visitors should admonish them. But if they do not bring their complaint, the consistory can announce that no complaint was lodged against the preaching and that the complainers may henceforth and forever hold their peace.
“3. The consistory shall see to it that all the consistory members are present at the meeting which is appointed for church visitation. Any member failing to be present shall be required to give the meeting a good reason for his absence. If one-half of the members are absent the visitation cannot be carried out.”
On this I have no remarks.
“4. The consistory shall see to it that the record books are at hand for the inspection of the visitors.”
On this, too, no remarks.
“5. Of the visitors, one shall function as chairman and the other as secretary. They shall record their findings and actions in a book, which can be consulted at the next visitation, and which can be kept in the classical archives.”
Also on this I have no remarks provided the first part of this decision be properly understood. I am afraid that it is often understood in such a way that the president of the visitors also functions as chairman of the consistory. This is not the idea. It is plain that the meeting for church visitation is a meeting of the consistory and not of the visitors. Hence, the chairman of the visitors should not even presume to be president of the meeting. That this is the meaning of this decision is also evident from the rest, namely, that the other shall function as secretary. This cannot possibly refer to the clerk of the consistory, but only to the secretary of the visitors.
“6. After completing the visitation of all the congregations, the visitors shall with requisite discretion, compose a report of their activities at the next following classis.”
No remarks.
For the questions prescribed for church visitation see pp. 59-61 of the Church Order.
In conclusion, I wish to state that the church visitors should accomplish their task as faithfully and thoroughly as possible. In order to do this they should not confine themselves to the prescribed questions in the back of our Church Order but should be at liberty to broaden out on them and give advice as occasion requires. For instance, they could easily broaden out on the second question to the full consistory: “Is the Heidelberg Catechism regularly explained in the services for Divine Worship, so that no doctrine is left untreated?” It is easy, of course, to answer Yes to this question and let the matter rest. But suppose that the purpose of the question is, too, to find out whether the minister is faithful in studying the doctrine explained in the Catechism and whether he himself remains ahead of the congregation in knowledge so that he may be able to continue to edify the congregation. Then it becomes a different matter. Then the church visitors might ask such questions as these: “Do you always make new sermons on the Catechism or do you simply put the old pile upside down? What sources do you study in connection with your Catechism preaching? Do you preach on the Catechism from different viewpoints? From what viewpoint are you preaching on it at present?” The same holds for many other questions. For instance, the question to the elders and deacons in the absence of the minister: “Does the minister reveal himself as a worthy example?” Again, it is easy to answer Yes and let it pass. But suppose you enter a little more deeply into the matter and ask: “How is his family-life? Is there harmony between man and wife? Are the children obedient to their parents? Are they allowed to visit places of amusements, theatres and movies? Are they allowed to turn on all kinds of radio and television programs?” etc., etc.
In one word, I hardly agree with the method of church visitation as it is conducted today.
Often, instead of spending thousands of dollars for church visitation one might better send a copy of the questions to every consistory, ask them to fill in the answers and ask whether they need any advice.
But that is not the purpose of Art. 44.
And it certainly was not the purpose of our Reformed fathers when they inserted this article in the Church Order.
—H.H.